Tuesday 12 March 2013

21 mistakes adding cost and killing productivity in your warehouse - #7


#7. Storing products in family groups, product code or description order or Bob* knows where

Before computerised systems warehouses were run entirely by manual paper based systems and human memory.  When there was a product to pick for and order there had to be some sort of system and logic to how stock was put-away so that individual items could be found.  Often stock was stored in family groups like in a supermarket where the same category of items are stored in the same area.  So long as the item you needed was there somewhere you would be able to find it if you looked hard enough.  

A variant of this is to store items alphabetically or numerically in code order.  This is a how  your local video store keeps its weekly video rentals (if you’re lucky), they will have family groups (drama, comedy, horror) and then put the videos in order by title.  If the warehouse and product range is very large and storing in logical product sequence becomes impossible then some variant of a stock locator card would be used to check product in and out of a numbered storage bay or location within the warehouse.

The problem with manual systems like this is that they continually break down due to the dynamic nature of modern business.  New products and product ranges come and go constantly.  A new product range takes off and needs a lot more space.  This means constant rearranging of stock to maintain order, which is very time consuming (i.e. expensive).  So what happens in practise is the rearranging either never happens or only when they system is very broken.  Stock will be put-away wherever it fits.  This is like the Drama section in your video store becoming full and the overflow going into the foreign language film section.  Maybe someone will stick on a post it note to tell you or you stumble upon this by accident or when you ask the staff they wave in the general direction and say “oh, that one’s in the foreign film section”.

The other problem with a manual logic based storage system are that too much time is lost searching for products even when everything is in order (which is almost never the case).  Once products are put where they fit instead of where they should be that search time can go up exponentially.  New hires have a long learning curve to become productive because the system becomes more based on memory and they have to ask an experienced colleague where things might be.  Bringing in a bunch of casual labour to help manage a peak in work or a stocktake can be an expensive and futile exercise.

Unfortunately too many businesses still run manual warehouse systems like this.  This is of course the fault of the modern business system. All the effort has been put into making the accounting and sales process efficient and little thought is given to the warehouse operations.  For example, SAP Business One does not even have an inventory location system (something I believe they are belatedly correcting).  Many business systems have basic location control of one location per product.  This is usually a text field added to the inventory file and not a separate location file allowing multiple items per location.  Whilst this is a major step up from nothing it does not give you the tools you need to run your warehouse efficiently.

The best solution to the problem is to invest in a Warehouse Management System (WMS) that will allow you to optimise the storage and physical product flows in your warehouse an eliminate the time lost in searching for products during picking or empty space during put-away.  These systems pay for themselves in around 3-6 months for medium and larger warehouses and 9-12 months for smaller warehouses with less than 10 staff.

If you are not ready to invest in a WMS then it may be possible to enhance your existing system with some new fields and revised reports to provide some basic functionality to improve what you have as an interim measure.  We have done this to great effect with SAP Business One but the same principles can be applied to most systems.  Bear in mind that if you go this route you are investing in a short term solution that you will throw away later and you should only do this if the WMS option is simply not viable for your business but you have to do something.  I strongly suggest that if you think you need to do something that you call us to discuss what your best options are.

* Bob is your longest serving warehouse operator.

This is post is taken from an ebook that is now available as a bonus to members of the Warehouse Performance Initiative (WPI*).


The WPI is a place for learning how to improve your knowledge of warehouse operations improvement, sharing skills and ideas and helping other warehouse professionals.  Joining the WPI will give you access to a growing range of free and premium content which will have a direct impact on improving your warehouse performance when you apply it to your business.


You can also subscribe to this blog by email and get my future posts delivered to direct your inbox.

No comments:

Post a Comment